How would everyone feel if the next round of the Definitive Legend of Zelda Review Thread was actually the Definitive Legend of Zelda Review Threads
I'm planning on the next round being in 2012, giving everyone a chance to explore and enjoy Skyward Sword, but I'm considering a bit of a shake up of the formula. Basically, each game gets its own thread (in a sub-forum, Mods? Pretty please?) and over the course of six months or perhaps most of the year, members old and new can post their thoughts and feelings about each game (perhaps doing a Rew/HS-style run through of the whole series but at a slightly softer pace) and score each on individual elements (story, design, sidequests, characters, etc - list in development and open to suggestions).
An average score is worked out and ranks awarded from then on.
In addition, members can post their favourite/least favourite NPCs, dungeons, etc and that can contribute to a more varied pool of entries in the Tingles and Navis.
And on top of that, a big deal could be made on the main site with guest reviews and things along those lines.
This is still pretty early-stage thinking, but I see it as an opportunity to boost discussion and membership. At least for the first year...